Next Post

NEXT POST WILL BE PUBLISHED ON OR
AROUND June 7, 2016.

SHOWN TO THE RIGHT, ARE THE CONTENTS OF THE 11/27/12 LETTER SIGNED BY PRIORITY ONE CREDIT UNION PRESIDENT, CHARLES R. WIGGINGTON, SR. IN COMPLIANCE TO THE TERMS OF SETTLEMENT AGREED TO BY THE CREDIT UNION AND A MEMBER WHO SUED THE CREDIT UNION, ALLEGING THEIR WILLFUL VIOLATION OF THE PRIVACY ACT.

Our Readership: U .S., Ukraine, Russia, France, Germany, United Kingdom, Poland, Malta, Malaysia, Laos, Canada, Greece, Turkey, Sweden, China, Taiwan, Hong Kong, Isle of Man, Portugal, Morocco and more!

Translate

SEARCH THIS SITE

Showing posts with label NCUA. Show all posts
Showing posts with label NCUA. Show all posts

Friday, May 15, 2015

Defining What's Normal, Part 1 of 3


Nowadays at Priority One Credit Union, headquartered in South Pasadena, California, "business as normal" has been displaced by fending off lawsuits. Its important to note that this dynamic did not exist at anytime during the 81 years preceding January 1, 2007, the date Charles R. Wiggington, Sr.  began serving as President and CEO of what was then a successful and growing Credit Union. 

Three lawsuits Priority One is currently litigating differ dramatically from those filed and voluntarily settled by the Credit Union during the years of 2010 through 2013. Those cases filed by four former employees and one Member, alleged violations of the Privacy Act, sexual harassment, same-sex sexual harassment, age discrimination, race discrimination, retaliation, and creation of a hostile work environment. The Credit Union paid out monies to avoid costly and potentially embarrassing court trials that would have produced documented records of abuses committed by the Credit Union's highest officers.

Two of the current batch of lawsuits, all filed in 2014, accuse the Credit Union and its President of various contractual related breaches while a third, filed by CUMIS, the Credit Union's insurance carrier, accuses the Credit Union's external auditors, Turner, Warren, Hwang, and Conrad of acting negligibly and failing to perform audits in compliance to established auditing standards. CUMIS also asserts that Turner, Warren, Hwang, and Conrad provided the Supervisory Committee erroneous information which in turn, compromised the integrity of the committee's annual performance assessments. CUMIS insists that the failures perpetrated by Turner, Warren, Hwang, and Conrad included not identifying thefts, perpetrated by Pearl Lynnette Fortson, a former AVP assigned to the Los Angeles branch, resulting in the theft of more than $1 million in cash from that branch's vault. 


As might be expected, CUMIS' allegations circumvent all reference to the Credit Union's and more specifically, the Supervisory Committee's responsibility to safeguard Credit Union and Member assets. Superficially, CUMIS' accusations seem absurd, eliciting questions about the actual theft and why so much responsibility is being placed on Turner, Warren, Hwang, and Conrad. Some of our questions are:  
  • How could Turner, Warren, Hwang, and Conrad be held accountable for the physical removal of $1 million in cash from the Los Angeles Branch's safe when the Credit Union's Accounting Department, the Chief Operations Officer, and the Supervisory Committee are responsible for all records documenting money sent to and received from the Credit Union's branches. ?
  • Why is CUMIS holding Turner, Warren, Hwang and Conrad responsible for thefts which occurred prior to their audit of the Los Angeles branch's ledgers? 
  • Turner, Warren, Hwang an Conrad were hired by the Credit Union to perform audits. The Supervisory Committee and President, delegated instructions to the firm as what records were to be audited. Did the instructions they provided include a request to audit vault cash and general ledgers located at the Los Angeles branch? 
In a few weeks, the Credit Union will serve as a witness in CUMIS' lawsuit. The Credit Union will also be a defendant in a lawsuit filed Turner, Warren, Hwang, and Conrad and in another lawsuit filed by Auto Alliance, one of Priority One's contracted automobile brokers. . Because the President is named a defendant, he will finally have to appear in court and provide testimony concerning the Credit Union's internal controls and answer questions which will almost certainly scrutinize his abilities as President and CEO and possibly even touch upon his ethics. However, we wouldn't be surprised if he stages excuses to try and avoid or prolong, having to, participate in litigation. In the past the wily but cowardly President took refuge behind Board Chair, Diedra Harris-Brooks, who freely approved spending Credit Union monies to hire overpaid and unscrupulous attorneys and useless consultants to create bogus defenses concoct fictitious facades that tried in earnest to depict the President as a victim, incapable of the atrocities described in lawsuits.  


A TREK DOWN MEMORY LANE



. 
In 2013, a lawsuit was filed by a former Branch Manager, which cited egregious acts committed by and under President Wiggington, former COO, Beatrice Walker, and the entire Human Resources Department. President Wiggington was named a defendant but his attorney at the time, Paul F. Schimley, of Richardson, Harmon and Ober contacted the plaintiff's attorney and told her that if she didn't remove President Wiggington's name as a defendant in the lawsuit, he would have to file a motion with the court informing them that the President was suffering from cancer and undergoing medical treatments that he said would force postponement of the lawsuit for months and possibly years. . 



CUMIS VS TWHC

We;'re intrigued by CUMIS' lawsuit. Though Turner, Warren, Hwang, and Conrad did not perpetrate the actual theft of $1 million in cash from the Los Angeles branch's safe, it is their competency, expertise and reputation will will be dissected in court and which ultimately is a threat to their reputation. 

CUMIS' investigation concluded that Turner, Warren, Hwang, and Conrad are responsible for failing to detect any of the individual thefts during audits conducted in 2010, 2011, and 2012. Due to their gross oversight, eventually the thefts would amount to more than $1 million in cash. In their lawsuit, CUMIS alleges malpractice, a type of violation most often associated with lawsuits filed against attorneys and physicians. Oddly, CUMIS fails to cite an exact date when the thefts started, merely stating that they began in "early" or "late" 2010 and continued through the end of 2012. Why couldn't they provide a more specific date when the thefts occurred? Shouldn't they have merely stated that "the thefts began sometime in 2010?" 

Who is Turner, Warren,Hwang and Conrad? 

We visited Turner, Warren, Hwang and Conrad's webpage and discovered that in 2013, a peer review was performed by Caldwell, Becker, Dervin, Petrick and Company, LLP. and In a letter dated June 30, 2013, and written to shareholders, Caldwell Becker, Dervin, Petrick and Company concluded: 
"In our opinion, the system of quality control for accounting and auditing practice.... for the year ending June 30, 2013, has been suitably designed and completed to provide the firm with reasonable assurance of performing and reporting in conformity with applicable professional standards in all material respects" and concluding, Turner Warren Hwang an Conrad ACE has received a peer review rating of pass."
Please note that the letter is dated only four months after the theft of $1 million was discovered by the Credit Union. Turner, Warren, Hwang and Conrad's website also contains the following overview of services they offer clients: 
TWHC's financial institutions practice provides a complete suite of services to credit unions of all sizes. Our credit union clients range from over $10 million to over $10 billion in assets. Our staff knows credit unions well. While the national firms we compete with call themselves specialists and the partner may have five or six credit union clients, our partners have in excess of 25 to 30 credit union clients each. 
We have a strong foundation built on our credit union practice. Our partners have worked for or with credit unions for over 20 years. We did not stumble onto credit unions or use them as filler time. We are dedicated to credit unions and have been from he beginning which is why we are ranked among the top five services providers to credit unions in the U.S. and are number one collectively in the states west of Arizona. 


Due to the length of CUMIS' lawsuit, we have decided to publish excerpts of only those allegations and statements we deem most important.  



As "subrogee", CUMIS has assumed the legal right to try and collect the monies paid out against the claim filed by the Credit Union. 



Former AVP, Pearl Lynnett Fortson, allegedly embezzled "at least $1,000,000" in cash, to wit, the amount was more than $1 million. She accomplished the thefts by allegedly "falsifying 'Daily Recaps", but how could the AVP, with or without accomplices, embezzle more than $1 million without detection by the Credit Union? Why did Priority One's internal controls designed to protect Credit Union assets fail to detect the thefts?

During the years of 2010 through 2012, Ms. Fortson's direct supervisors were COO, Beatrice Walker and later, CLO, Cindy Garvin, and finally, current Vice President of Operations, Yvonne Boutte. Over an approximate twenty-four period, why didn't any of the three overpaid and evidently, unqualified executives ever notice any of the several incidents during which money was embezzled? 




Turner, Warren, Hwang and Conrad's attorney may have told a reporter of the CU Times that Priority One never "expressed" disappointment with the services and decisions made by his client but the Credit Union's Supervisory Committee and CUMIS found sufficient evidence to conclude that Turner, Warren, Hwang and Conrad violated laws and provided fraudulent data that in turn caused the Supervisory Committee to derive erroneous conclusions about the Credit Union's actual performance. Since the Supervisory Committee is a governing body of Priority One Credit Union and because CUMIS' is the subrogee of the Credit Union, it appears Priority One was indeed, extremely disappointed with Turner, Warren, Hwang and Conrad's "actions." 



 

Under #19, CUMIS states that Priority One's Supervisory Committee is appointed by the Credit Union's Board of Directors and "tasked with the responsibility of obtaining an audit of the Credit Union's financials using an independent external auditor. But is the report provided from an "independent audit" the only source used by the Supervisory Committee to assess the Credit Union's performance and to gauge its ability to protect Member and Credit Union assets. 







Under #29, above, CUMIS states that during the years of 2011-2012, the Supervisory Committee was the recipient of Turner, Warren, Hwang, and Conrad's reports which provided findings obtained from audits; and similarly, Turner, Warren, Hwang and Conrad "expected" the Supervisory Committee to "rely on the thoroughness, accuracy, integrity, independence and overall professional caliber of audits it performed. Wouldn't it seem reasonable that a firm providing services to numerous Credit Union's and whose peer review cites an adherence to industry standards, make every effort to ensure the information provided to the Supervisory Committee was accurate and obtained from a thorough review of Priority One's records? 




Many past employees of the Credit Union can testify that documentation presented to auditors was always first reviewed by Executive Vice President, Rodger Smock, who was seen pulling out documents he did not wish presented to auditors. His censorship was intended to obstruct the disclosure of any information which could reveal breaches in procedure. 

CUMIS has chosen to accuse Turner, Warren, Hwang and Conrad of violating professional auditing and ethical standards and alleges the firm failed to properly examine Credit Union "books, records, and general ledgers." We expect the accounting firm to provide more than statements from the Credit Union that supports their accusations including providing lists of what documents the President and Supervisory Committee ordered to be included in any number of audits. Because as CUMIS asserts, Turner, Warren, Hwang and Conrad were hired by the Credit Union and paid to perform a service, was the accounting and auditing firm ever instructed not to audit certain credit union records?  Ultimately, it was the Credit Union who retained full control over what should and what should not be audited.  





It's seems more than a tad hypocritical that since Charles R. Wiggington, Sr. was appointed President on January 1, 2007, that the Credit Union has been sued several times and accused of egregious violations of state and federal laws, yet CUMIS and the Credit Union have no problem leveling accusations impugning the accounting and auditing firm and accusing them of violating "their professional auditing and ethical standards by failing to ever review or test the cash accounts at" the Los Angeles Branch.

In December 2009, then CFO, Manny Gaitmaitan, resigned but before leaving, confided to some members of his staff that he had been ostracized by President Wiggington; COO, Beatrice Walker; and then Senior Vice President, Rodger Smock, for his refusal to manipulate financial reporting." We hope that CUMIS is prepared to address questions regarding the Credit Union's reporting practices. 


 


In late 2009, TWHC conducted a three-week audit at the Los Angeles Branch and found that more than $60,000 had been stolen by a former receptionist. During the entire three-week audit conducted in a back office at the branch, AVP, Lynnette Fortson sat alongside auditor, Terry Nabors, while he examined Member and branch records. At the time, we found her inclusion in the audit both a conflict of interest and inappropriate but President Wiggington took absolutely no issue with her involvement. Could it be she sat alongside the auditor because she was concerned that he might uncover incidents that would reveal she was involved in the thefts of money? 





CUMIS accuses Turner, Warren, Hwang and Conrad of failing to count vault cash. Had they counted vault cash and reconciled those amounts with what was recorded in the vault's general ledger or reviewed the balancing sheets prepared by AVP, Fortson, they would have discovered the "fraud and embezzlement" committed by the AVP. Priority One has an internal auditor- Diane Huffman who should have been sent to each of the Credit Union's three remaining branches to audit records and count vault cash. Why wan't this done? And what about the responsibility the President, the COO, and the Accounting Department have to reconcile ledgers, balance sheets and cash records? 

CUMIS chose to pay out more than $980,000 against the $1 million claim filed by the Credit Union in 2013. We assume they agreed to pay the claim because their investigation proved that the Credit Union following all security protocols, yet this was the second large theft to occur at the Los Angeles Branch within a three-year period.  

  • How did the Credit Union respond following the discovery in 2009, that a former receptionist absconded with more than $60,000 from the Los Angeles branch?
  • What changes did Priority One introduce to its security procedures following discovery that more than $60,000 had been stolen by a former receptionist? 
We have to question CUMIS' wisdom. Why didn't the insurance company provide a more exact date when the theft of $1 million in cash began? According to their complaint, the thefts started either in "early" or "late 2010". Why not just state that the thefts began sometime in 2010?  We hope Turner, Warren, Hwang and Conrad have retained records showing what they were asked to audit. 






CUMIS requests the courts order Turner, Warren, Hwang, and Conrad to pay damages and all costs spent to file and litigate the lawsuit and any additional monetary relief deemed just and proper by the court.  

In his article, Strong Internal Controls Reduce Employee Dishonesty, dated August 20, 2014, Theran Colwell writes:

 "When a credit union catches an employee embezzling funds or committing other fraud, it must investigate and implement procedures to close the security breach."

Again, what changes did the Credit Union introduce following the discovery that more than $60,000 had been stolen by a former receptionist sometime in early 2009?

More importantly, why did the changes the Credit Union should have introduced fail to deter the series of thefts that started in "early" or "late" 2010 and continued, unnoticed, through late 2012?

In his article, Mr. Colwell also states: 
  • Lead from the top with a written policy
  • Create a system of checks and balances, including a clear segregation of duties
  • Review cash-handling procedures and refresh staff training
Source: http://news.cuna.org/articles/39429-strong-internal-controls-reduce-employee-dishonesty

REVISITING THE 2013
SUPERVISORY COMMITTEE'S ADDRESS 

We are once again revisiting the Supervisory Committee's address which appeared int he 2013 Annual Report. The report was first distributed to attendees of the Annual Meeting which took place at Priority One's main branch in South Pasadena, California on May 27, 2014. 




The Supervisory Committee's Chair composed her address in 2014, approximately one year after Priority One discovered the theft of $1 million from the Los Angeles branch's vault. And though the series of thefts took place during the years of 2010 through 2012, the Supervisory Chair included the name of Turner, Warren, Hwang, and Conrad in her address published in the 2013 Annual Report which was first distributed on May 27, 2014. 

Why would Ms. Simmons make reference to the firm if she knew that CUMIS had concluded that Turner, Warren, Hwang, and Conrad had been remiss in their audits and allegedly caused the Credit Union to lose $1 million in cash? 

In her address, Ms. Simmons states, "The Supervisory Committee has the responsibility of overseeing the internal and external auditors of the Credit Union", adding, "The external audit firm of Turner, Warren, Hwang & Conrad Certified Public Accountants and Consultants conducts a comprehensive annual financial audit with verification of member accounts each year." 

Three conspicuous facts standout:

#1: In February 2013, Priority One's Internal Auditor discovered that $1 million had been embezzled from the Los Angeles Branch's vault. 

#2: CUMIS filed its lawsuit against Turner, Warren, Hwang and Conrad in April 2014. 

#3: Ms. Simmons address to Members was published in the annual report first distributed in May 2014, one month after CUMIS filed its lawsuit.  

We've also reviewed several of the Credit Union's annual reports for the years preceding 2013 and failed to locate a single address signed by Ms. Simmons and which alludes to Turner, Warren, Hwang and Conrad or any other external auditing firm hired by Priority One. 

So why did Ms. Simmons reference Turner, Warren, Hwang and Conrad's name in the 2013 Annual Report? Ms. Simmons is clearly stating that her Committee relies on whatever findings are provided by Turner, Warren, Hwang and Conrad. Is her disclosure a feeble and all too transparent attempt to free the Supervisory Committee of all culpability in the theft of $1 million?

Priority One may be a state-chartered Credit Union but its assets are federally insured by the NCUA. We obtained the following excerpt Cornell University Law School's Legal Information Institute, describing the role of a credit union's Supervisory Committee. 

12 CFR 715.3- General Responsibilities of the Supervisory Committee

§ 715.3 General Responsibilities of the Supervisory Committee


(a) Basic. The Supervisory Committee is responsible for ensuring that the Board of Directors and management of the Credit Union-
(1) Meet required reporting objectives; and 
(2) Establish practices and procedures sufficient to safeguard member assets.

(b) Specific. To carry the responsibilities set forth in paragraph of this section, the Supervisory Committee must determine whether:
(1) Internal controls are established and and effectively maintained to achieve the credit union's financial reporting objectives which must be sufficient to satisfy the requirements of the Supervisory audit, verification of Member accounts and additional responsiblities. 
(2) The Credit Union's accounting records and financial reports are promptly prepared and accurately reflect operations and results: 
(3) The relevant plans, policies, and control procedures are established by the Board of Directors are properly administered; and
(4) Polices and control procedures are sufficient to safeguard against error, conflict of interest, selfing dealing and fraud. 

CUMIS' lawsuit places responsibility for the theft of $1 million on Turner, Warren, Hwang and Conrad even though it is the Supervisory Committee who is ultimately responsible for the implementation of internal controls that effectively protect Credit Union and Member assets. 
  • So what corrective measures did the Supervisory Committee implement in response to the 2009 theft of more than $60,000 perpetrated at the Los Angeles branch by a former receptionist? 
  • Why did the Credit Union's internal controls fail to identify any of several thefts perpetrated over the years of 2010 through 2012? 
  • And how often does the Supervisory Committee convene and what records can they provide of the topics discussed during each meeting and the actions taken to improve Priority One's internal controls? 
On a side note, it's important to note in 2008, Cornelia Simmons along with Board Directors, Diedra Harris-Brooks; O. Glen Saffold; and Thomas Gathers, voted and won reinstatement of President Wiggington despite overwhelming evidence that he sexually harassed a former employee and following urging by the investigator that the President be terminated. .These attest to her ethics and ability to hone decisions based on a fair and impartial assessment of evidence. 

The Supervisors like the Directors, are ignorant and unable to carryout their state-mandated duties. They and the Directors depend on the President to interpret financial data contained in the Credit Union's financial reports. Does this at all seem like a conflict of interest and immensely inappropriate? It's time the Supervisors and Directors were administered tests to gauge their competency. And one has to wonder, why procedures developed and/or approved by the Supervisory Committee have continually failed to protect assets administered by the Los Angeles branch.

CONCLUSION

It doesn't take an expert or even an in depth study of Priority One's monthly, quarterly, and annual reports to realize that this Credit Union's issues run deep and are terribly awry. What should be seen as perplexing is that the President, his executive and managerial staff, the Board of Directors and the Supervisory Committee are all apparently so out of touch that they can't understand the relationship that exists between internal conflicts, security breaches, abuses of authority, dishonest business practices, and the Credit Union's struggle to acquire new business and membership.

CUMIS Insurance is hoping to that their accusations against Turner, Warren, Hwang and Conrad will possess sufficient merit and be so compelling that a a jury (which they've requested) will issue a judgment in their favor. 

However, CUMIS will have to contend with questions about the Credit Union's subpar security procedures which failed to stop the theft of $60,000 in 2009 and the theft of $1 million in cash during the years of 2010 through 2012. The looming question we have is how could the Credit Union's allegedly well-developed security procedures fail so miserably? 

Here is a record of some lawsuits filed against or involving Priority One since October 2010? 

1. Lawsuits filed by four former employees during the years of 2010 through 2013, alleged sexual harassment, same-sex sexual harassment, retaliation, age discrimination, and creation of a hostile working environment. 

2. The filing of a lawsuit in 2012 by a former Member which accused the Credit Union of violating the Privacy Act.

3. The 2014 filing of a lawsuit by Alliance Auto, one of Priority One's contracted automobile brokers, alleging a breach in contract. 

4. The 2014 lawsuit filed by CUMIS against Turner, Warren, Hwang, and Conrad and alleging it is the accounting firm's satisfactorily perform its duties compliant to established standards resulted in the loss of $1 million in cash stolen by a former AVP. 

5. The 2014 filing of a lawsuit by Turner, Warren, Hwang and Conrad against Priority One Credit Union.

The lawsuits are all symptoms of a bigger, more serious problem afflicting Priority One and indicative of why the once successful Credit Union is nowadays a smaller, no longer competitive, and disliked Credit Union. The internal turmoil saturating the Credit Union explains in part, why Priority One was forced to close 6 of 9 branches during the period of 2010 through 2014. The Credit Union has spent years, desperately raising its net capital all for the mere purpose of retaining their operation. In 2008, its net capital dropped down to almost 6% and at the time, both the DFI an NCUA informed the President that he had better find an immediate means by which to reduce expenses and raise capital. His closures, however, could not stave-off the continued decline in net income which dropped by approximately $22 million since January 1, 2007.

President Wiggington's business failures are exacerbated by his personal conduct which has been appalling and embarrassing. In 2008, an investigation proved he sexually harassed a former employee though fortunately for the President, his ally, Board Chair, Diedra Harris-Brooks, ignored and suppressed the evidence and led two other Directors and Supervisory Committee Chair, Cornelia Simmons, to vote for his reinstatement despite the fact the investigator urged his termination. 

In the end, a victory in court will be gotten by the attorney who presents the most convincing argument. For CUMIS, this isn't a slam dunk as they have chosen to continue a business relationship with an organization led by a notorious President and corrupt Board of Directors and evidently, ineffective Supervisory Committee. On the other hand, Turner, Warren, Hwang, and Conrad chose to enter into and maintain a business relationship with the infamous Credit Union and as of May 2015, their well-earned reputation in the industry is at stake.  




l

Tuesday, August 11, 2009

Internal Thefts and Cover-Ups

BRAINSTORMING

Last week, Priority One Credit Union conducted a two-day strategic meeting at its main branch located in South Pasadena, California. 

President Charles R. Wiggington, Sr. presented his plan to the Board of Directors which he promises will dredge the credit union out of its financial slump which has left it impaled in the RED. We can't understand how the man who caused the credit union's decline is going to, after three years, implement corrective measures that will reverse the causes of the credit union's decline. 

On another front, auditors from Turner, Warren, Hwang and Conrad have been working out of the Los Angeles branch, examining transactions processed by a former receptionist who resigned from the credit union after departing on maternity leave. 

The President has also informed staff members in the South Pasadena branch that business improved during the month of July. So do we accept his statements at face value or do should we ask Charles R. Wiggington. Sr. to provide evidence supporting his claims?

A MEETING OF THE MINDS

On Wednesday, August 5, 2009, and Thursday, August 6, 2009, Charles R. Wiggington, Sr. met with members of the Board of Directors. During what he has referred to as "a brainstorming session", the President disclosed his plan on how to jump start business, reduce delinquencies, increase membership, and increase loan development. 

The only barrier we see to the President's plans is the President, himself. President Wiggington has consistently failed since 2007, to create strategies that achieve their intended goals. Under his leadership, the credit union has lost millions of dollars of net income. In 2008, he purchased a telephone system that he insisted would bring an end to member service complaints and that would replace the need for a call center. Less than one year later, he is planning the installation of a call center because his $600,000 phone system which he selected without the assistance of any of his executives, has failed. So are we to believe that the same person who is most pivotal for the credit union's decline, is also the same person who will restore business and repair its decrepit public reputation? By the way, Priority One remains well embedded in the RED. 

Following his two day brain storming session, the President emerged more confidant, more jovial and more arrogant. Unfortunately, for President Wiggington, lip service is no substitution for actual results. Well, maybe to most people except the ignorant Board of Directors. 

The Board of Directors, under leadership of its Chair, Diedra Harris-Brooks, is made up of a body of wholly ignorant and ineffective officers. Each month, they require that the President interpret the credit union's financial performance reports. Its a clear conflict of interest, but something the Board is incapable of comprehending.  

The meeting was also attended by the AVP of Lending, Patricia Loiacano; the Director of Credit Resolutions, Yvonne Boutte; and so-called Training and Education Manager, Robert West. Noticeably absent, AVP, Rodger Smock. 

Though the President has asserted he is reducing spending, "streamling" and "working smarter", he had the two-day meeting catered proving again that the President has no inhibitions of splurging money that isn't his own.   
FINANCIAL FACTS

The Credit Union's Monthly Income Statement for the month of June 2009, discloses that delinquencies exceed 4%. At no time, in recent years, have delinquencies been so high. The report also reveals that during the month of June, the credit union paid $58,000 in interest against the $20 million loan borrowed by the President in mid-2008.  Priority One's capital also declined to 7%, nearing the dreaded 6% which all credit union wish to avoid. 

INTERNAL THIEVERY

No bank or credit union can avoid the incidence of internal thefts, though procedures and polices are created to ensure that occurence of these is reduced or all together stopped. Over the years, Priority One's Los Angeles Branch, former known as the LAPDC, has been the site of internal thievery. 

2000

Priority One used to sell Travelers Cheques. In the year 2000, an audit discovered that a large number of these had been stolen and cashed. The Supervisory Committee initiated an investigation but the stolen monies were never recuperated nor did the committee ever discover who perpetrated the theft. At the time, Charles R. Wiggington was the credit union's, Vice President of Operations.  

2002


In 2002, Henry Justice, the owner of Justice Auto Sales and close friend of Charles R. Wiggington, Sr., accepted $85,863.63 cents from the credit union covering the costs of vehicles purchased from the dealer by four employees of the credit union. Mr. Justice refused to surrender the pink slips for each vehicle and absconded with the money paid to him in good faith. 

As a result of the incident, the four members- S. Alexander, L. Aranda, I. Shell and J. Crawford could not obtain their Registration Cards. Over the next few years, the credit union's DMV Specialists were forced to visit the Department of Motor Vehicles each month to obtain temporary stickers that would serve in lieu of Registration Cards.

The credit union sued Mr. Justice, but the dealer filed for bankruptcy (11 U.S.C. §§523(A) (2), (4) AND (6)) and court discharged Mr. Justice's debt allowing him to escape have to repay the credit union the monies he had stolen. 


2008

In 2008, Mr. Wiggington, Sr. met with Mr. Justice on two separate occasions. During each meeting, employees could hear loud laughter coming from the President's office. Apparently, the two were reminiscing over the good old days. After their meeting ended, the President visited AVP, Patricia Loiacano and informed her that he was reinstating a business relationship with Mr. Justice and his son's dealership. 

The President told Mrs. Loiacano that he would be printing fliers promoting the dealership and that in a few days, business cards for the new Justice Auto and Sales, would be distributed to every employee of the Loan Department. He also said that once fliers and business cards were distributed, loan department personnel would be ordered to only recommend Mr. Justice's dealership which meant the President was severing the credit union's long standing relationship with Universal Leasing and Sales. 

So why would President Wiggington resurrect a business relationship with a man who absconded with more than $83,000 of credit union monies? We have to conclude that Charles R. Wiggington, Sr. doesn't care about the credit union , its members or its employees and as is typical with the horrendous President, he constantly rewards wrong. It's just who he is. 

Fliers were printed and a few days later, Mr. Justice visited the South Pasadena branch, delivering a box of his business cards.  The President's plan seemed unstoppable, at least to the President. Here is information obtained from Mr. Justice's business card:



LONG'S AUTO SALES
Henry Justice/Dealer
800.863.KARS (5277)
Office: 310.768.3506
Fax: 310.768.4111
Cell: 310.739.7206
451 E. Carson Plaza Drive, Suite 204, Carson, CA 90746

Always pay less than retail
All vehicles CARFAX certified
Warranties available in all makes and models



Unfortunately, the President;'s hurried efforts to reinstate Mr. Justice were disrupted. The first impediment occurred when Mrs. Loiacano reminded him that Mr. Justice had absconded with more than $83,000 of credit union monies. She insisted that Mr. Justice be asked to pay back a portion of what he had taken. The President contacted Mr. Justice who agreed to repay $1300.00. 

Unknown to the President, the Loan Department staff decided they would not recommend Mr. Justice and would continue promoting Universal Leasing and Sales. 

The third blow to the President's plan was this blog. We exposed his efforts to reinstate Mr. Justice. On the day we published our post reporting the return of Mr. Justice, President Wiggington rushed into the Loan Department and asked every loan processor and officer to return the business cards he had passed out a few days earlier. When Board Chair, Diedra Harris-Brooks called to ask if what she read was true, he denied our report and said it was an attempt to slander his character. After ending his call with Mrs. Harris-Brooks, he called Mr. Justice and told him, that should anyone call and ask if he entered into an agreement with the credit union, that he should say it wasn't true. 

2009

Under President Wiggington and with the assistance of AVP, Rodger Smock, credit union policies are enforced inconsistently, with disciplinary actions strictly enforced against employees President Wiggington doesn't like and all together circumvented for employees who the President favors. In fact, some of the worst violators of policy have been promoted by the corrupt President. 

On June 1, 2009, the credit union hired its first COO, Beatrice Walker. As we've reported in previous posts, her arrival was understated and without fanfare and though she was introduced by name while AVP, Rodger Smock, led her through the South Pasadena branch, he never alluded to her title nor did he disclose what her role would be at the credit union. 

Recently, Ms. Walker stood before employees of all offices during one of the credit union's quarterly, all-staff meetings and for some inexplicable reason said that she responded to an ad in an unnamed newspaper, seeking a COO, She was called by the Board, who interviewed her and offered her the post. And she concluded by stating that she'd never met President Wiggington prior to her arrival at the credit union. There was just a little too much effort made by Ms. Walker to ensure everyone understood she never met President Wiggington prior to her June 2009 arrival at the South Pasadena branch. We don't intend any disrespect, but we don't believe her story. 

Following conclusion of the all-staff meeting, the South Pasadena Branch Manager, Gema Pleitez; the lead Consumer Loan Officer, Georgina Duenas; and FSR, Jennifer Preciado, told employees that one year earlier, the three women were walking towards Appleby's restaurant in the city of Alhambra. While crossing the parking lot, they noticed President Wiggington leaving the restaurant with Ms. Walker. For some reason, the three employees ran and hid behind an automobile, and watched as the President and Ms. Walker walked passed them without ever noticing the three crouching females. They told employees that the President and Ms. Walker were laughing and apparently joking with one another. 

Evidently, Ms. Walker lied when she placed tremendous emphasis on her statement that she never met President Wiggington prior to being hired by the Board. So why lie? Apparently, the President and Ms. Walker have some thing to hide. 

We were recently provided information about a case presided over the the NCUA in the case of Kennae Rakee Jeffries. Mr. Jeffries is a former temporary employee of Honda Federal Credit Union in Torrance, California, and at the time worked under supervision of Beatrice Walker. We've copied excerpts of the document which has since been removed by the NCUA from their website.  . 



III. Findings of Fact, page 2

“Respondent Kennae Rakeem Jeffries was employed by Honda Federal Credit Union from February 2002 Until October 2003. In May and June, 2002, using his access to FCU account systems, Respondent opened FCU accounts and obtained FCU VISA credit cards for his grandparents, Leroy and Joyce Douglas. Neither Respondent nor his grandparents were eligible to open such accounts. Respondent initially obtained supervisory approval to raise the credit limits on the two VISA cards, and then unilaterally increased the limits on each VISA card to $25,000, the maximum allowed. Respondent did not have the authority to do so. Respondent charged both of the VISA credit cards to their $25,000 maximum to pay his own personal expenses. Respondent caused the FCU to suffer an aggregate financial loss of $61,541.75, consisting an aggregate past due balance of $48,229.06 and accrued interest of $13,312.69. In order to avoid showing delinquencies in the two VISA card accounts, Respondent kited funds between the two VISA accounts and his own account. He also twice altered the FCU’s general ledger diverting the FCU’s retained earnings in order to bring the VISA card accounts current and to avoid showing a delinquency on the VISA accounts.” 

Under “Recommended Decision and Order”, Discussion, Paragraph 4, Page 2:

“Enforcement Counsel’s motion is supported by the sworn declaration of Steven L. Brandon, the chief operating officer of the credit union, and Beatrice Walker, manager of the credit union branch at which Respondent was employed as a member service representative. The Brandon declaration and credit union records attached thereto as exhibits detail how Respondent, using a former Honda employee’s membership number, created VISA credit card accounts for his grandparents, who were neither credit union members nor eligible for membership, and then increased their credit card limits, all without authority or proper authorization.”

Paragraph 2, page 5, continues:

“Walker, in her sworn declaration attests that she did not give Respondent permission or approval to open an account for any one who was not a credit union member, nor assist him by filling in an applicant’s employee identification number or mailing account application forms to anyone on his behalf. Walker further attests that she understands records indicate that she approved a request to increase the credit limit on one of the Respondent’s grandparents accounts and that she would not have approved such a request had she known the person ineligible to be a credit union member, was a relative of Respondent or that Respondent opened or controlled the account.”

Paragraph 1, page 4 further states:

“Respondent admits creating the VISA credit card accounts but asserts his manager approved them and increased the intial limits on them from $5000 to $10,000, apparently without reviewing the Douglas’ credit which would have shown their undischarged bankruptcy filing ( 6 – 8). Respondent identifies his supervisor as Bea Arthur rather than Beatrice Walker ( 6 – 8).



ACTUAL FINDINGS AND CONCLUSIONS OF THE LAW, Article 5, states: 


Without revealing his relationship to the account holders or that they had filed for bankruptcy, he obtained supervisory approval to increase the credit limit on one VISA credit card account from $5000 to $10,000.



The docket discloses that Beatrice Walker approved the increase of one of the cards without properly reviewing the application and the account holder's history. If she had, she might have realized that the account holder did not qualify for a $25,000 credit card. She also might have noticed that the signature was forged by the temporary employee who was under her supervision. 

Ms. Walker did not authorize opening of either of the accounts which were opened in the names of the Defendant's grandparents. She also did not approve an increase of the credit limit on one of the cards. The NCUA determined that the former employee must pay restitution in the amount of $61,541.75 plus interest. Despite her apparent negligence, Ms. Walker found a high paid position at Priority One Credit. And though while at Honda Federal Credit Union, she inadvertently violated credit union policy, she now oversees compliance at Priority One Credit Union.

August 2009

The President recently disclosed that a member who often banks at the LAPDC branch reported that her CD, opened in the amount of about $6000 had been closed and later reopened in the amount of $3000. According to the President, the culprit is a former receptionist who while employed by the credit union, pillaged member accounts, including CD's and IRA's. The President said "someone is going to pay for this." 

AVP, Lynnette Fortson, who oversees the Los Angeles branch has disclosed that her office's records are being audited by Turner, Warren, Hwang and Conrad and according to the AVP, the crime was reported to the FBI, though rather conspicuously, no one from the FBI has visited the branch. 

The entire incident is unfortunate but brings into question the effectiveness of Priority One's security protocols. And what happened to the credit union's tagline which tells members, "You Are Our First Priority." We of course, disagree. A few weeks ago, the President revealed the credit union's mission statement is being rewriting by Training and Education Manager, Robert West. The new statement describes Priority One as a "Fitness Center" possessing the ability to help members "win with money." We again have to disagree. 

So why did a year go by without Priority One ever noticing that monies had been embezzled from member accounts? The thefts were discovered because a member lodged a complaint, asserting someone had stolen from from her CD. Priority One is either not doing its due diligence to ensure all employees perform security measures or its procedures are in dire need of a make-over. However, it is important to realize that one of the worst perpetrators who chronically circumvents polices and procedures is President Wiggington. 

A HISTORY OF BREACHES

We're uncertain how the President will deal with this latest internal theft. When one considers that he hired a COO who while serving as supervisor of Honda Federal Credit Union's call center, failed to adhere to procedure and created the opportunity for one of her employees to abscond with $61,541.75. Not conducting a proper background check of Ms. Walker is but one of many breaches of security committed by President Wiggington. 

In 2007, he promoted Liz Campos even when knowing she incurred more than 24 individual NSF incidents to her Priority One checking account. An investigation revealed she had kited using checking accounts from three different financial institutions. The President denied all knowledge of the abuses and quickly blamed the Member Services Department for failing to advise him of the violations, however, an investigation also revealed that he had authorized the reversal of every NSF incurred by Mrs. Campos. 

In 2008, President Wiggington tried to reinstate a working relationship with Henry Justice, the owner of Justice Auto Sales. A few years earlier, Mr. Justice absconded with more than $80,000 of credit union paid to him for automobiles purchased from his dealership by four members. Mr. Justice filed for bankruptcy which was approved by the court and allowed him to escape having to repay any of the monies stolen years earlier. Despite Mr. Justice's egregious act, President Wiggington thought it prudent to re-enter into a working relationship with his friend, Henry Justice. 

Earlier this year, he lied to the DFI, denying that he had refused to post the credit union's Monthly Income Statements at any of the credit union's branches. A few weeks ago, having grown weary of what he described as the DFI's prying, the President finally conceded the resuming posting of the statements. 

He also purchased without consulting his executive staff, a $600,000 telephone system that has proven to be a technical fiasco and has forced the credit union to spend hundreds of dollars each month for the services of telephone technicians who have yet to resolve the system's widespread issues. 

It was also President who eliminated the Marketing Department because according to him, it didn't fit his "vision" for the marketing. If his vision was reducing new business, then his plan was phenomenally successful. 

The last Assistant Branch Manager of the Los Angeles office discovered that the book containing instructions for opening the branch's ATM was kept in unlocked desk drawer and not inside the vault as stipulated by policy. Anyone in the branch could have taken the book and used it's information  to remove money from the ATM. 






# block visitors referred from indicated domains RewriteEngine on RewriteCond %{HTTP_REFERER} semalt\.com [NC,OR] RewriteCond %{HTTP_REFERER} semalt\.com [NC] RewriteRule .* - [F]